State Your Business!

An Evaluation of World Bank Group Support to the Reform of State-Owned Enterprises, FY08-18

This is IEG’s first systematic assessment of World Bank Group’s support for the reform of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), looking at what works and the factors of success. It parallels Bank Group efforts to provide more integrated support to SOE reform in client countries and to empower staff with new tools.

An Evaluation of World Bank Group Support to the Reform of State-Owned Enterprises, FY08-18
Published:

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) play a major role in many developing and emerging economies, where governments use them to achieve economic, social, and political objectives. SOEs deliver and extend access to services, fill gaps in markets, develop key sectors or regions, and provide employment. However, SOEs’ mixed institutional mandates and their political importance often pose performance, financial, and governance challenges. 

This is IEG’s first systematic assessment of the World Bank Group’s support for the reform of SOEs, looking at what works and the factors of success. It parallels Bank Group efforts to provide more integrated support to SOE reform in client countries and to empower staff with new tools. The evaluation focused on five major types of SOE reforms in the financial and energy sectors:

  • Corporate governance improvements 
  • Business and operational reforms  
  • Measures to strengthen competition and regulation in SOE markets  
  • Privatization and other ownership reforms (including PPPs)  
  • Macro, fiscal, and public financial management (PFM) reforms.  

 

The evaluation includes findings about the impact of competition on SOE performance; corruption control and its effect on SOE reform; the success of Bank Group sequential and complementarity interventions; and other factors that aid success such as client commitment, collaboration, strong design features, solid results frameworks and monitoring, and early risk identification.  

Based on the findings and lessons of experience drawn from this evaluation, IEG offers management two recommendations to enhance the Bank Group’s support to SOE reform:  

  1. The World Bank Group should apply a selectivity framework for SOE reform support that considers country governance conditions, control of corruption, and sector- and enterprise-level competition. 
  2. The World Bank Group should apply the Maximizing Finance for Development and its embedded Cascade approach for SOE reform.